When Does ICT-Enabled Citizen Voice Lead to Government Responsiveness?

Tiago Peixoto, Jonathan Fox
Volume 47 Issue 1
Published: 24 January 2016
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.19088/1968-2016.104
Abstract: This article reviews evidence on the use of 23 information and communications technology (ICT) platforms to project citizen voice to improve public service delivery. This meta-analysis focuses on empirical studies of initiatives in the global South, highlighting both citizen uptake ('yelp') and the degree to which public service providers respond to expressions of citizen voice ('teeth'). The conceptual framework distinguishes two roles played by ICT-enabled citizen voice: informing upwards accountability, and bolstering downwards accountability through either individual user feedback or collective civic action. This distinction between the ways in which ICT platforms mediate the relationship between citizens and service providers allows for a precise analytical focus on how different dimensions of such platforms contribute to public sector responsiveness. These cases suggest that while ICT platforms have been relevant in increasing policymakers' and senior managers' capacity to respond, most of them have yet to influence their willingness to do so.


From Issue: Vol 47, No 1 (2016) | Opening Governance


Bayern, J. (2015) Investigating the Impact of Open Data Initiatives: The Cases of Kenya, Uganda and the Philippines, Washington DC: World Bank

Belcher, M. and Abreu-Lopes, C. (2016, forthcoming) 'MajiVoice Kenya: Better Complaint Management at Public Utilities', Digital Engagement Evaluation Team document, Washington DC: World Bank

Berdou, E. and Abreu-Lopes, C. (2015) 'The Case of UNICEF's U-Report (Uganda): Final Report to the Evaluation Framework for Digital Citizen Engagement', Digital Engagement Evaluation Team document, World Bank, unpublished

Bhatti, Z.K.; Zall Kusek, J. and Verheijen, T. (2015) Logged On: Smart Government Solutions from South Asia, Washington DC: World Bank

Brockmyer, B. and Fox, J. (2015) Assessing the Evidence: The Effectiveness and Impact of Public Governance-oriented Multi-stakeholder Initiatives, London: Transparency and Accountability Initiative, www. transparency-initiative.org/reports/assessing-the-evidence-the­effectiveness-and-impact-of-public-governance-oriented-multi­stakeholder-initiatives (accessed 6 October 2015)

Carothers, T. and Brechenmacher, S. (2014) Accountability, Transparency, Participation and Inclusion: A New Development Consensus?, Washington DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, http://carnegieendowment.org/files/new_development_consensus.pdf (accessed 6 October 2015)

Cornwall, A. (2002) Beneficiary, Consumer, Citizen: Perspectives on Participation for Poverty Reduction, SIDA Studies 2, Stockholm: Swedish International Development Agency

Diecker, J. and Galan, M. (2014) '"Creating" a Public Sphere in Cyberspace: The Case of the EU', in E.G. Carayannis, D.F. Campbell and M.P. Efthymiopoulos (eds), Cyber-Development, Cyber-democracy and Cyber-defense, New York NY: Springer

Fox, J. (2014) Social Accountability: What does the Evidence Really Say?, GPSA Working Paper 1, Washington DC: World Bank Global Partnership for Social Accountability Programme

Fox, J. (2007) 'The Uncertain Relationship between Transparency and Accountability', Development in Practice 17.4: 663–71

Fung, A.; Gilman, H.R. and Shkabatur, J. (2013) 'Six Models for the Internet + Politics', International Studies Review 15: 30–47

Fung, A.; Graham, M. and Weil, D. (2007) Full Disclosure: The Perils and Promise of Transparency, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

Gaventa, J. and McGee, R. (2013) 'The Impact of Transparency and Accountability Initiatives', Development Policy Review 31(S1): 3–28

Gigler, S. and Bailur, S. (eds) (2014) Closing the Feedback Loop: Can Technolog y Close the Accountability Gap?, Washington DC: World Bank

Grandvoinnet, H.; Aslam, G. and Raha, S. (2015) Opening the Black Box: Conceptual Drives of Social Accountability Effectiveness, Washington DC: World Bank

Joshi, A. (2014) 'Reading the Local Context: A Causal Chain Approach to Social Accountability', IDS Bulletin 45.5: 23–35

Lieberman, E.; Posner, D. and Tsai, L. (2014) 'Does Information Lead to More Active Citizenship? Evidence from an Education Intervention in Rural Kenya', World Development 60: 69–83

Masud, M.O. (2015) Calling Citizens, Improving the State: Pakistan's Citizen Feedback Monitoring Program, 2008–2014, Princeton NJ: Princeton University, Innovations for Successful Societies, http://successfulsocieties.princeton.edu/publications/calling-public­empower-state-pakistan (accessed 13 October 2015)

Mellon, J.; Peixoto, T. and Sjoberg, T. (2015) 'The Crowd Never Lies? Evaluating the Quality of Crowd-sourced Data in Uganda', Digital Engagement Evaluation Team document, World Bank, unpublished

Peixoto, T. (2013) 'The Uncertain Relationship Between Open Data and Accountability: A Response to Yu and Robinson's The New Ambiguity of "Open Government"', UCLA Law Review Discourse 60: 200–48

Peixoto, T. and Fox, J. (2015) 'When Does ICT-enabled Citizen Voice Lead to Government Responsiveness?', Background Paper, 2016 World Development Report, World Bank Digital Engagement Evaluation Team, unpublished

Prieto-Martín, P.; de Marcos, L. and Martínez, J.J. (2011) 'The e-(R) Evolution Will Not Be Funded', European Journal of ePractice 15: 62–89

Ranganathan, M. (2012) 'Reengineering Citizenship: Municipal Reforms and the Politics of "quot;e- Grievance Redressal" in Karnataka's Cities', in R. Desai and R. Sanyal (eds), Urbanizing Citizenship: Contested Spaces in Indian Cities, Thousand Oaks CA and New Delhi: Sage

Spada, P.; Mellon J.; Peixoto, T. and Sjoberg, F.M. (2015) Effects of the Internet on Participation: Study of a Public Policy Referendum in Brazil, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 7204, Washington DC: World Bank

Susha, I. and Grönlund, Å. (2014) 'Context Clues for the Stall of the Citizens' Initiative: Lessons for Opening Up E-participation Development Practice', Government Information Quarterly 31.3: 454–65

UNICEF (2012) U-report Application Revolutionizes Social Mobilization, Empowering Ugandan Youth, www.unicef.org/infobycountry/uganda_62001.html (accessed 13 October 2015)

World Bank (2015) 'Digital Analysis', World Bank Digital Evaluation Team document, unpublished

World Bank (2014a) Strategic Framework for Mainstreaming Citizen Engagement in World Bank Group Operations, Washington DC: World Bank, https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/21113 (accessed 13 October 2015)

World Bank (2014b) Survey Report: Citizen Feedback Monitoring Program, Washington DC: World Bank