The Dark Side of Digital Politics: Understanding the Algorithmic Manufacturing of Consent and the Hindering of Online Dissidence

Emiliano Treré
Volume 47 Issue 1
Published: 24 January 2016
Abstract: Various strands of literature on civic engagement, 'big data' and open government view digital technologies as the key to easier government accountability and citizens' empowerment, and the solution to many of the problems of contemporary democracies. Drawing on a critical analysis of contemporary Mexican social and political phenomena, and on a two-year­long ethnography with the #YoSoy132 networked movement, this article demonstrates that digital tools have been successfully deployed by Mexican parties and governments in order to manufacture consent, sabotage dissidence, threaten activists, and gather personal data without citizens' agreement. These new algorithmic strategies, it is contended, clearly show that there is nothing inherently democratic in digital communication technologies, and that citizens and activists have to struggle against increasingly sophisticated techniques of control and repression that exploit the very mechanisms that many consider to be emancipatory technologies.


From Issue: Vol 47, No 1 (2016) | Opening Governance


Andio´n Gamboa, M. (2013) 'Las Redes Sociales Virtuales como Medios Alternativos al Poder de la Telecracia en México', Versio´n 31: 42–55

Aristegui Noticias (2012) La Cargada de Funcionarios en Twitter a Favor de #reformaenergética,­cargada-de-funcionarios-en-twitter-a-favor-de-reformaenergetica/ (accessed 7 October 2015)

Boyd, D. and Crawford, K. (2012) 'Critical Questions for Big Data: Provocations for a Cultural, Technological, and Scholarly Phenomenon', Information, Communication and Society 15.5: 662–79

Couldry, N. (2010) Why Voice Matters: Culture and Politics after Neoliberalism, Los Angeles CA: Sage

Couldry, N. and Powell, A. (2014) 'Big Data from the Bottom Up,' Big Data and Society July–December: 1–5

Crawford, K.; Gray, M.L. and Miltner, K. (eds) (2014) 'Big Data, Big Questions', special section in International Journal of Communication 8, (accessed 7 October 2015)

Davies, T. and Bawa, Z. (2012) 'The Promises and Perils of Open Government Data (OGD)', Journal of Community Informatics, (accessed 7 October 2015)

Dean, J. (2005) 'Communicative Capitalism: Circulation and the Foreclosure of Politics', Cultural Politics 1.1: 51–74

Espino Sánchez, G. (2012) ¿Cyberrevolucio´n en la Poli´tica? Mitos y Verdades Sobre la Ciberpolitica 2.0 en México, México: Distribuciones Fontamara

Ferrara, E.; Varol, O.; Davis, C.; Mensczer, F. and Flammini, A. (2015) The Rise of Social Bots, 1–11

Figueiras, L. (2012) 'El Movimiento Estudiantil en el Proceso Electoral 2012', in L. Figueiras (ed.), Del 131 al #YoSoy132. Eleccio´n 2012, México: Comunicacio´n y Política Editores

Fuchs, C. (2014) Social Media: A Critical Introduction, London: Sage

Galloway, R.A. and Thacker, E. (2007) The Exploit, Cambridge MA: MIT Press

Hallinan, B. and Striphas, T. (2014) 'Recommended for You: The Netflix Prize and the Production of Algorithmic Culture', New Media and Society, early/2014/06/23/1461444814538646 (accessed 13 October 2015)

Huerta-Wong, J.E. and Go´mez García, R. (2013) 'Concentracio´n y Diversidad de los Medios de Comunicacio´n y las Telecomunicaciones en México', Comunicacio´n y Sociedad 19: 113–52

Islas, O. (2015) Los Neoectivistas: El Recurso contra la Participacio´n Ciudadana, la_participacion_ciudadana./35375/ (accessed 7 October 2015)

Islas, O. and Arribas, A. (2012) Enseñanza y Ejemplo de la Primavera Mexicana, Razo´n y Palabra, V80/19_IslasArribas_V80.pdf (accessed 7 October 2015)

McGee, R. (2014) 'Making All Voices Count: Government Responsiveness. Making All Voices Count Think Piece', eldis, (accessed 13 October 2015)

Milan, S. (2015) 'When Algorithms Shape Collective Action: Social Media and the Dynamics of Cloud Protesting', Social Media and Society 18.8: 887–900

Morozov, E. (2013) To Save Everything, Click Here: The Folly of Technological Solutionism, Philadelphia PA: Public Affairs

Mosco, V. (2014) To the Cloud: Big Data in a Turbulent World, New York NY: Paradigm

Orcutt, M. (2012) 'Twitter Mischief Plagues Mexican Election', MIT Technolog y Review,­mischief-plagues-mexicos-election/ (accessed 7 October 2015)

Ricaurte Quijano, P. (2013) 'Tan Cerca de Twitter y tan Lejos de Los Votantes: Las Estrategias de los Candidatos Presidenciales Mexicanos durante la Campan~a Electoral de 2012', Versio´n 31: 118–32

Trejo Delarbre, R. (2004) Poderes Salvajes. Mediocracia sin Contrapesos, México DF: Cal y Arena

Treré, E. and Barassi, V. (2015) 'Net-authoritarianism? How Web Ideologies Reinforce Political Hierarchies in the Italian 5 Star Movement', Journal of Italian Cinema and Media Studies 3.3: 287–304

Treré, E. and Barranquero, A. (2013) 'De Mitos y Sublimes Digitales: Movimientos Sociales y Tecnologías de la Comunicacio´n desde una Perspectiva Histo´rica', Revista de Estudios para el Desarrollo Social de la Comunicacio´n 8: 27–47

Tuckman, J. (2012) 'Mexican Media Scandal: Secretive Televisa Unit Promoted PRI Candidate', The Guardian, 26 June,­scandal-televisa-pri-nieto (accessed 30 October 2015)

Tufekci, Z. (2014) 'Engineering the Public: Big Data, Surveillance and Computational Politics', First Monday, index.php/fm/article/view/4901/4097 (accessed 7 October 2015)

Verkamp, J-P. and Gupta, M. (2013) 'Five Incidents, One Theme: Twitter Spam as a Weapon to Drown Voices of Protest', unpublished presentation from 3rd USENIX Workshop on Free and Open Communications on the Internet, Berkeley, California

Villamil, J. (2010) El Sexenio de Televisa: Conjuras del Poder Media´tico, México DF: Grijalbo

Yu, H. and Robinson, D. (2012) 'The New Ambiguity of Open Government', UCLA Law Review Discourse 178,­ambiguity-of-%E2%80%9Copen-government%E2%80%9D/ (accessed 7 October 2015)